In his prescient 2006 article in Wired, Jeff Howe coined the term crowdsourcing
to describe how the Internet has enabled large, distributed teams of amateurs to do work that was previously the domain of isolated experts or corporations. Linux and Wikipedia are only two of hundreds of examples of this phenomenon. Howe's article in Wired focused on two innovative companies who had successfully harnessed the power of crowdsourcing: iStockphoto, a community-driven source for stock photography, and InnoCentive, where corporations offer cash prizes for solving their thorniest research and development problems. Two years later, Howe has expanded his article into a 300-page book:
Crowdsourcing: Why the Power of the Crowd is Driving the Future of Business.
I'm a fan of Wired, and this is exactly the kind of book that I would normally love, but in this case I found myself disappointed. If you've already read Howe's article in Wired, and indeed if you are the kind of person who reads Wired, you won't find much that is new or surprising here. Howe fills up his 300 pages by repeating the same examples over and over. For example, we learn that iStockphoto is so cool that Getty Images finally bought them out. It's a nice story, but Howe can't resist telling it in what seems like every chapter. If you sometimes feel like you're reading the same sentence twice, that's because you are. Here's Howe on page 134 describing idea jams
:
People have pointed out that this is little more than an Internet-enabled suggestion box. Just so. The Internet didn't make crowdsourcing possible--it just made it vastly more effective.
A nice observation, but then the identical sentences appear again on page 159. This kind of editorial sloppiness abounds. On page 51, Howe mangles the the recursive acronym of the GNU project. On page 237, he repeats the widely believed but false claim that Xerox PARC invented the computer mouse (it was SRI).
Howe proudly announces that this book itself was crowdsourced
--he put drafts on his website for the crowd to critique and edit. He probably should have hired a professional editor instead, who would have cut it in half and made it a great book.
Website Optimization
The Logic of Life: The Rational Economics of an Irrational World